Skip to content. | Skip to navigation

Personal tools

Commentaries on this Media!

Fandom Referendum: Fan Cultures and Civic Embodiment

by Ethan Tussey

by Christopher M. Cox for IN MEDIA RES

Pop culture conventions such as Comic-Con International (CCI) facilitate an increasingly frictionless relationship between fans and producers of cultural content. They simultaneously offer fans access to creators and celebrities, while providing industry tradespersons an enthusiastic audience primed as conduits of franchise support. The locus of this dynamic occurs in panels, wherein featured guests and promotional materials are offered to fans, usually culminating in a discourse between fans and panelists. Relations among producers and consumers might be easily conjured by this mix of participants, yet the rituals of Comic-Con also embody forms of democracy practiced in traditional government proceedings. Panelists are introduced, carry out sanctioned discussions, and invite questions from audience members, just as civic bodies take roll, deliberate governmental affairs, and invite feedback from the electorate. At CCI, questions posed by fans to panelists often demonstrate an indebtedness that points towards obligations emblematic of government's responsibility to its citizenry. Asking "when will Thanos show up in the Avengers?" is not merely meant to satisfy a curiosity - it intends to provoke assurances not dissimilar to those expected by a city councilperson faced with the question "when will water usage rates decrease?"

"Article Two," a 2013 episode of the television show Parks and Recreation, extends this concept of the fan as civic actor to a space of official government proceedings. Garth Blunden, a resident of the fictional Pawnee, Indiana, filibusters at a city council meeting to prevent a series of archaic laws from being overturned. The content he chooses for his dialogue is a personal vision for the forthcoming Star Wars sequel. Exasperated, the council board and meeting attendees depart the courthouse, leaving the episode to resolve the matter outside of council affairs.

Embodiment of civic engagement in the context of fan cultures portends questions of its trajectories. Does fan culture provide unique tools for better democratic involvement? Is fan culture able to mobilize its constitutive members towards other political and social arenas? And, if barriers between fans and cultural producers continue to erode, can pop culture fandom provide a sustainable model for reimagining democratic forms?

Representing Democracy and Filibustering

Filed under:

A clip from Parks and Recreation

from Filibustering with Star Wars and Marvel (2013)
Creator: NBC
Distributor: YouTube
Posted by Ethan Tussey