Skip to content. | Skip to navigation

Personal tools
Sections

Commentaries on this Media!

Mohamedou Ould Slahi’s Guantánamo Diary: Dismantling Ideologies of Fear and Torture

by Ethan Tussey

by Alexandra Moore for IN MEDIA RESGuantnamo Diary (2015)written by Mohamedou Ould Slahi, redacted by the U.S. government, and edited by Larry Siemsis the only account of Guantnamo from a current detainee. Since 2002, Slahi has been held at the naval base, where he underwent a special recipe of torture approved by the Secretary of Defense and now awaits a Periodic Review Board hearing on June 2. Slahi divides his time into pre- and post-torture, when his brake broke looseand [he] yessed every accusation [his] interrogators made. Notwithstanding those forced (and he says, false) confessions and his indefinite detention without charge, Slahi seeks to understand the ideological forces mobilized against him as well as to initiate a dialogue with his readers.
The website for the book, www.guantanamodiary.com, attests to the book's veracity and power and promotes Slahis case. The 466-page handwritten manuscript, with heavy redactions, is on-line, offering proof of its provenance. Audio clips read by actors including Colin Firth, Benedict Cumberbatch, and John Hurt give weight to Slahis words. Accompanying them is a video comprised of animation, voice-over excerpts, and interviews with Slahis brother, editor, and attorney. The first three minutes state the case for Slahis release: they couple his experience of torture with the lack of evidence of terrorism; present him as a modern renaissance man with close familial relationships; explain his brief alliance with Al-Qaeda in the early 1990s in Afghanistan, when it was a tacit US ally; and cast doubt on the US governments trustworthiness, as when Slahis brother asks, How can a government lie to us for so long?
Whereas the website works to publicize Slahis case and defend him in the public sphere, Guantnamo Diary is a complex narrative that defies easy categorization. As Lauren Beard writes, Slahis narrative shifts from the perspective of a victim caught in the crossfires of the war on terror to the perspective of an outsider studying and analyzing a foreign culture. That culture includes the strategic manipulation of law that authorizes torture and detention without charge as well as the relationship between guards and interrogators and their prisoner. In another essay, Kori Hall takes Slahi at his word: He wants readers to immerse themselves in his story and to gain a better understandingfor a type of person that we might fear simply because we do not know them.

Mohamedou Ould Slahi’s Guantánamo Diary: Dismantling Ideologies of Fear and Torture

by Ethan Tussey

by Alexandra Moore for IN MEDIA RESGuantnamo Diary (2015)written by Mohamedou Ould Slahi, redacted by the U.S. government, and edited by Larry Siemsis the only account of Guantnamo from a current detainee. Since 2002, Slahi has been held at the naval base, where he underwent a special recipe of torture approved by the Secretary of Defense and now awaits a Periodic Review Board hearing on June 2. Slahi divides his time into pre- and post-torture, when his brake broke looseand [he] yessed every accusation [his] interrogators made. Notwithstanding those forced (and he says, false) confessions and his indefinite detention without charge, Slahi seeks to understand the ideological forces mobilized against him as well as to initiate a dialogue with his readers.
The website for the book, www.guantanamodiary.com, attests to the book's veracity and power and promotes Slahis case. The 466-page handwritten manuscript, with heavy redactions, is on-line, offering proof of its provenance. Audio clips read by actors including Colin Firth, Benedict Cumberbatch, and John Hurt give weight to Slahis words. Accompanying them is a video comprised of animation, voice-over excerpts, and interviews with Slahis brother, editor, and attorney. The first three minutes state the case for Slahis release: they couple his experience of torture with the lack of evidence of terrorism; present him as a modern renaissance man with close familial relationships; explain his brief alliance with Al-Qaeda in the early 1990s in Afghanistan, when it was a tacit US ally; and cast doubt on the US governments trustworthiness, as when Slahis brother asks, How can a government lie to us for so long?
Whereas the website works to publicize Slahis case and defend him in the public sphere, Guantnamo Diary is a complex narrative that defies easy categorization. As Lauren Beard writes, Slahis narrative shifts from the perspective of a victim caught in the crossfires of the war on terror to the perspective of an outsider studying and analyzing a foreign culture. That culture includes the strategic manipulation of law that authorizes torture and detention without charge as well as the relationship between guards and interrogators and their prisoner. In another essay, Kori Hall takes Slahi at his word: He wants readers to immerse themselves in his story and to gain a better understandingfor a type of person that we might fear simply because we do not know them.

Gitmo and Guards

Guardian documentary on Guantanamo

from Guantánamo Diary: torture and detention without charge (2015)
Creator: The Guardian
Distributor: YouTube
Posted by Ethan Tussey
Keywords
Genres
Options